
I finished reading James Acaster’s new book, Perfect Sound Whatever. I know James from the BBC & YouTube, where he is a regular guest on panel shows and solo stand-up comedy appearances. I bought this book expecting some good laughs; that didn’t happen. There are moments of humour scattered through the book, delivered in classic James Acaster deadpan style. The heart of the book is not about humorous events in his life; it is about his life and his relationship with music and people through one specific year, 2016, with a few bits from other years.
For those who know me, it is no secret that I am passionate about music. I listen to music, a lot of music. James Acaster listens to a lot of music as well, and our tastes overlap a surprising number of times considering our age gap; he is 41, I am 71. In this book, James walks us through a year in his life and the music he listens to during that year and beyond. He makes the bold statement that 2016 was the Greatest Year of All Time. GYoAT? The Greatest (Year) Of All Time, GOAT? Specifically, James asserts that 2016 was the greatest year in music of all time, and he walks us through all the music he listened to that year, with short album reviews along the way.
James includes a calendar at the end of the book with an album for each day of the leap year, 366 albums. He also includes an appendage because he listened to a lot more than just those 366 albums.
I loved the book and plowed through it way too fast. I will have to revisit the reviews at a more pedestrian pace, giving myself time to listen to the music, perhaps not all 366, but samples of them all and deeper listens for ones that catch my ear, or his synopsis resonates with me. This will not be a year-long process, hopefully, but I do intend to listen to some music from 2016 that is new to me. I have already listened to or owned several of the albums listed and have listened to several of the albums that James Acaster listened to from his 2016 list.
| Pink Floyd | Meddle |
| Joe Cocker | Gold |
| Mal Devisa | Kiid |
| George Harrison | All Things Must Pass |
| Zeal & Ardor | Zeal and Ardor |
| Christian Fitness | This Taco Is Not Correct |
| Jeff Beck | Truth |
As seen above, I listened to more than just James Acaster’s albums; I know they aren’t his albums, but you know what I mean. I also listened to some good older tunes.

Pink Floyd are one of my top bands to listen to. I can go through their entire catalogue up to a certain point, and then it loses its appeal. The turning point is The Wall. The Wall is still listenable, but I find my mind wandering as I listen; it doesn’t hold me as much as their earlier material. On the other hand, I can listen to Meddle several times a year. With The Wall, once a year is enough. I think that may be an incendiary statement to some, who will strongly defend The Wall. I would posit, however, that they perhaps don’t have the career-spanning experience that I have had with Pink Floyd. I am of the opinion that a lot of younger fans are only familiar with the DSotM to The Wall period in the Pink Floyd discography.



Meddle is the sixth studio album by Pink Floyd and is separated from DS0tM by only one album, Obscured By Clouds, which was written as a soundtrack, not a stand-alone studio album. Meddle is significant in the timeline of Pink Floyd because it is the fulcrum that moved the band away from the Syd Barrett era into the Gilmour, Mason, Waters, Wright era. On Meddle, the song composition was a group effort, whereas Waters would dominate the lyrics in future albums.
The band started using more studio effects on Meddle, effects that would show up frequently in later albums. It is easy to hear the influence of Meddle as a precursor to DSotM, and influence that had a ripple effect through the remainder of their catalogue, with the possible exception of their last four albums, Final Cut, Momentary Lapse of Reason, Division Bell, and Endless River. The Final Cut is the last Pink Floyd album to feature founding member Roger Waters, who left the band in 1985. It is the only Pink Floyd album without founding member and keyboardist Richard Wright, who had left the band under pressure from Waters after the Wall sessions.
Back to Meddle for a moment. The album opens with One of These Days, which is mostly instrumental, with a howling wind followed by a thundering bass line for a few measures, then the other instruments. It is a great intro because of the pounding bass throughout, including the bass drum and keyboards. Gilmour noodles on guitar throughout, tying the song together. The band fill side one with four more tracks that offer some contrast from the cohesive structure of future Pink Floyd albums. Side two of Meddle is the epic Echoes, 231⁄2 minutes long. Echoes was used by different members of the band through their solo careers and is considered by many to be the definitive transition point from the little-known band with an avid cultish following to a mainstream band. It is considered by many to be one of the band’s best cuts. Several publications have remarked on it as one of the best songs by the group. Pink Floyd themselves have mixed views of the track, but it was a particular favourite of Richard Wright’s.

Joe Cocker Gold was a thrift store find that made a good listen for the drive home. It is loaded with top ten hits and sing-along songs.

I don’t think I had ever sat down and listened to All Things Must Pass start to finish. I was, of course, familiar with his radio-friendly hit singles “My Sweet Lord” and “What Is Life“. I can’t say that listening to the album start to finish caused me to jump up and run to Record Collectors Paradise to buy a copy. While I worked in the store’s warehouse, we sorted plenty of copies of the album, and most of the covers were in tatters, with vinyl condition that hovered around VG. I’ll have to revisit this album sometime in the future, perhaps even on physical format if I can find a good one at the right price. Music prices have gone through the roof!

I have long admired the guitar virtuoso Jeff Beck, and I have several physical copies of his music that I revisit periodically. My favourite is Jeff Beck with the Jan Hammer Group Live. I had read someone praising the Jeff Beck album Truth, which I had not heard, so I gave it a spin. Truth is Jeff Beck’s debut album and features a stellar lineup of musicians. The core members of The Jeff Beck Group on this and most of his early albums were Rod Stewart on vocals and Ronnie Wood on guitar. Additional cast included:
- John Paul Jones – bass guitar on “Hi Ho Silver Lining” and “Beck’s Bolero”; Hammond organ on “Ol’ Man River” and “You Shook Me”; arrangements on “Hi Ho Silver Lining”
- Nicky Hopkins – piano on “Morning Dew”, “You Shook Me”, “Beck’s Bolero” and “Blues Deluxe”
- Keith Moon (credited as “You Know Who”) – drums on “Beck’s Bolero”; timpani on “Ol’ Man River”
- Madeline Bell – backing vocals on “I’ve Been Drinking”
- John Carter and Ken Lewis – backing vocals on “Tallyman”
- Clem Cattini – drums on “Hi Ho Silver Lining”
- Aynsley Dunbar – drums on “Tallyman” and “Rock My Plimsoul (single version).”
- Jimmy Page – 12-string Fender Electric XII guitar on “Beck’s Bolero
An impressive assortment of musicians that make an enjoyable album. I will add this to my already too long want list.

One of the albums that James Acaster talked about was Kiids by Mal Devisa. I was hooked on this album after the first song and basked in the rest of it. On the album Kiid, Mal opens with a simple ballad of her voice and a guitar, Fire. She has a good voice that carries the emotion of the lyrics well. Then, in the last 30 seconds of the track, the gentle acoustic guitar transforms into a hard rocker with a scream in the background and a harder edge to Mal’s voice. The second track, In My Neighbourhood, opens with a delicious bass line. I won’t go into detail on each track, but suffice to say that this whole album deserves more than one listen, and it deserves to be more than background noise; it demands paying attention and asking yourself what is going on both lyrically and instrumentally. I have lost count of how many times I have listened to Kiid; suffice to say that it will be an end-of-year candidate.

Zeal and Ardor is another of James Acaster’s picks. He listened to their album Devil is Fine, which was quite enjoyable. It wanders between blues, black gospel and industrial metal. I don’t know if I will listen to their music again; it is good, but I confess that I don’t listen to much doom/industrial/metal music—a bit of an acquired taste on this album. Interesting lyrics, I will add. Don’t give up on the album after hearing only one or two tracks; it is much more diverse than those two songs. There are touches of blues, a smattering of black gospel and even what sounds like a harpsichord in their songs. Diverse and challenging, in a good way.

This Taco Is Not Correct is a great album title; it caught my attention and made me curious to find out what the heck is going on. The band name is also interesting: Christian Fitness. I want a physical copy, unfortunatly they are sold out. It is still a good listen streaming; I’m just old school and like vinyl. I have spun this album around a couple of times, and I keep hearing it differently each time. I like that. I don’t want to miss anything, so I have to focus and listen intentionally. The music is all over the place when it comes to genre. It could be alternative rock, indie rock, garage, metal, or even noise rock. I don’t care what label it gets; I like the music.
So, there we have it, another week of great tunes. I look forward to next week and another batch of new (to me) music and some old favourites.































































